- Rupee has witnessed massive depreciation from Rs123 against the US dollar in August 2018 to Rs177 in December 2021.
- The only other higher devaluation occurred when Dhaka fell when Pakistan’s currency was devalued by 58%.
- Experts say massive devaluation of currency under the PTI government fueled inflationary pressures.
ISLAMABAD: The Pakistani rupee’s value against the US dollar has fallen by 30.5% during the incumbent PTI-led government’s tenure, as per a report in The News.
The rupee witnessed massive depreciation from Rs123 against the US dollar in August 2018 to Rs177 against the US dollar in December 2021, over the last 40 months. This makes it one of the highest devaluations of the currency in the country’s history.
The only other higher devaluation occurred when Dhaka fell and Pakistan’s currency was devalued by 58% from Rs4.60 to Rs11.10 against the US dollar in 1971-72.
Many independent economists argue that this recent devaluation of the currency was dictated by the IMF through prior actions and it has nothing to do with macroeconomic fundamentals.
Dr Ashfaque Hassan Khan, a former economic adviser, said that there was a complete breakdown of economic policymaking as the country’s fiscal policy had become subservient to monetary and exchange rate policies. He said that the monetary tightening and exchange rate depreciation resulted in higher inflation, public debt and debt servicing. The empirical evidence showed that the 1% monetary tightening hiked the inflationary pressure by 1.3% in Pakistan’s case.
Experts say this massive devaluation of currency under the PTI government fueled inflationary pressures, adding that two major factors contributed to the price hike. First, the prices of food and commodities, as well as fuel prices, skyrocketed in the international market, and second, the depreciation of the exchange rate by 30.5% also led to higher inflation.
Some studies conducted by economists suggest that 10% devaluation of the currency raised the Consumer Price Index (CPI)-based inflation by 0.6%. As a result, the 30.5% depreciation resulted in increasing inflationary pressures by approximately 2%. This indicates that from the inflation standing at 11.5% on a monthly basis, nearly 2% comes through depreciation of the exchange rate.
An analysis of regional currencies versus the US dollar shows that the Pakistani currency experienced massive depreciation compared to others.
The Indian rupee stood at 75.39 against a US dollar. The Indian rupee stood at Rs70.09 against the US dollar in 2018, Rs73.66 in December 2019, Rs74.53 in March 2020 and Rs74.57 in April 2021.
In the case of Bangladesh, the Bangladeshi Taka stood at 85.76 against the US dollar and it hovered around 84 to 85.9 on average over the last two years.
Meanwhile, the Pakistani rupee continued to fall in value and stood at Rs177 against a US dollar in December 2021. It depreciated sharply from Rs123 against to Rs177 against a dollar over the last three years and four months.
Rupee and Instability
During the Musharraf-Shaukat Aziz regime between 1999 and 2007, the country’s currency remained largely stable and hovered around Rs60 against a US dollar. When the PPP-led regime came to power in 2008, the rupee depreciated as a result of a rising current account deficit and slid to Rs80 just in a few months.
Then, the rupee further adjusted against the dollar in a gradual manner after Pakistan joined the IMF program and remained around Rs90 against the US dollar from 2008 to 2013. In June 2013, the currency stood at Rs98.5 against the US dollar.
Then, the PMLN came to power in 2013. In November 2013, the Pakistani currency stood at Rs107.5 against the US dollar. Former finance minister Ishaq Dar’s policies brought the rupee down to an average rate of Rs98 against the US dollar in June 2014.
The Pakistani rupee remained stable at Rs100 in August 2014 while it adjusted slightly and settled at Rs105 against the US dollar in 2015-16 and 2016-17. Then, former finance minister Miftah Ismail allowed adjustment of the rupee against the dollar and it nosedived to Rs118 against US dollar in June 2018.
The rupee continued to slide during the interim rule of a caretaker government. However, when the PTI-led regime joined the government in August 2018, the rupee stood at Rs123 against the US dollar.
Then, Pakistan joined the IMF programmer and the rupee on average further depreciated and stood at Rs155 against the US dollar in June 2019. Till April 2020, the rupee continued to depreciate to Rs164 against the US dollar. In August 2020, the rupee touched Rs167.7 against the US dollar.
For a brief period, till April 2021, the rupee strengthened and remained on average at Rs152 against the US dollar. Since April 2021, however, the Pakistani currency witnessed a fresh wave of depreciation as the rupee on average touched Rs156 against the US dollar in June 2021, Rs168 in September 2021 and Rs170 in November 2021. In December 2021, the rupee crossed Rs177 against US dollar.
On average, the CPI-based inflation has hovered around 8.2% between 1991 and 2020-21. However, now the CPI-based inflation has crossed double-digits and touched 11.53% in November 2021. There are other factors fueling higher inflation but the massive devaluation of the rupee also played a key role in the surge in prices over the past few months.
Economist Dr Zafar Mahmood said that the increased foreign exchange reserves help countries to maneuver, but with limited reserves, there is less room a country to stabilise its currency. Pakistan needs to build up its foreign currency reserves with non-debt-creating inflows such as exports, remittances, and foreign investments.
Sajid Amin Javed, an economist from SDPI, said that the depreciation of the currency over the last three years had actually accumulated in the last eight years because the value of the rupee was artificially raised.
He said if data of the past decade was analysed, it would show that India and Bangladesh had allowed depreciation when it was required. If data from 2016 to 2018 was analysed, it would show that Pakistan’s current account deficit worsened but the rupee remained stable; while in India there was a lesser current account deficit but the Indian rupee depreciated from Rs63 to Rs71 against the US dollar.
He said Pakistan kept its rupee on the higher side and so accumulated depreciation occurred. He termed this phenomenon as “forced depreciation” as the foreign currency reserves depleted and the current account deficit widened. He said the events in Afghanistan also added pressure on Pakistan’s exchange rate.
Pakistan, he said, joined the IMF programme so it was left with no other option but to ensure implementation on the forced depreciation. “The main problem lies with our policies as it also triggers panic and uncertainty,” he added.
Originally published in